The owners of a Staffordshire Moorlands house look set to have their request to cut down two trees on their property thrown out.
An application has been lodged to fell two sycamore trees at the address on Saltersford Lane, Alton.
The two trees are subject to a Tree Protection Order – with a previous scheme to cut them down thrown out in 2004.
Now a council report has said the application should be refused.
The owners of the property have raised a number of concerns about the trees, including:
- The height of the trees concerning their neighbours due to potential damage if they fell.
- The trees blocking the light to another neighbouring property
- The sycamores dripping sap onto cars and damaging paintwork
- The two trees stunting the growth of a nearby oak tree.
Two new oak saplings would be planted if the trees are cut down.
In the report, a Staffordshire Moorlands District Council Arboricultural Officer stated that ‘the reasons for the application are not considered to justify such work’.
If you’d like the top stories of the days sent free to your inbox, we have you covered with a daily email.
Sign up by clicking here.
Or you can type your email address into the ‘sign up to free daily alerts’ box. It’s at the top of this article.
The report said: “Large trees can inevitably give rise to concern over the potential for damage, and injury; however, such concerns can be aimed at any number of trees but perception of potential danger should not in itself be regarded as reason to allow removal of protected trees whenever requested on a precautionary basis.
“The applicants do not suggest the trees are in poor or dangerous condition, nor have they provided any evidence or report identifying condition-based concerns.”
Regarding the nearby house having its light affected the reported: “This property stands across the lane from the application site, to the north of the trees, and given their size and grouping they will inevitably cast a significant amount of shade.
“However, this is an inevitably natural consequence arising from the presence of trees, and is not considered to provide justification for the loss of protected trees.
“The proposed felling of T1 and T2 would result in the total loss of amenity value currently provided by these mature tree, which jointly with other trees in the immediate vicinity form a notable landscape feature contributing to the character of the site and the wider local area, and the reasons for the application are not considered to justify such work.”
Staffordshire Moorlands District Council’s planning committee will make a decision on the application at their meeting on Thursday.